| Year |
Winner |
Runner-up |
| 1997 |
Chris Snyder |
Todd Clift |
| 1998 |
Todd Clift |
Roger Letterman - Joyce Newland |
| 1999 |
Rick Philabaum |
Jay Patterson - Eugene Paik |
| 2000 |
Drew Price |
Ray Beebe - Dick Sekula |
| 2001 |
Bob Rhodes |
Dave Tolbert |
| 2002 |
Mark Newland |
Ray Beebe |
| 2003 |
Jay Patterson |
Lee Morrow - Bob Rhodes - Dick Sekula |
| 2004 |
Jay Wasson |
Roger Letterman |
| 2005 |
Mark Newland - Doug Wray |
(none) |
| 2006 |
DJ Knotts |
Ray Beebe - Roger Letterman |
| 2007 |
Roger Letterman |
Dennis Lee - Patrick Brady - Rick Philabaum |
| 2008 |
Dennis Lee |
Doug Wray - Dan Labus - Mark Starzynski |
| 2009 |
Phil Perry |
Rick Philabaum |
| 2010 |
Doug Wray |
Rex Bowser - Dan Labus - Martha O'Conner |
| 2011 |
Dan Labus |
Janusz Johnson - Dan Stamatkin |
| 2012 |
Chris Hammack |
Rex Bowser |
| 2013 |
Bob Rhodes, Rex Bowser |
(none) |
| 2014 |
Rick Philabaum |
Mark Newland |
| 2015 |
Dan Labus |
Mike Jenkins |
| 2016 |
Dan Labus |
Martha O'Conner, Joyce Newland |
| 2017 |
Kenny Franklin |
Doug Griffin |
| 2018 |
Dan Labus |
Ray Beebe, Bob Rhodes |
| 2019 |
Doug Wray |
Ken Leuderalbert |
| 2020 |
Chris Hammack |
Joyce Newland |
| 2021 |
Kurt Darling |
Roger Letterman, Mark Starzynski |
| 2022 |
Chris Hammack |
Isaac Collis |
| 2023 |
Dan Stamatkin |
Chris Hammack |
| 2024 |
Pat Colcord |
Allen Egilmez, Randy Fischer |
| 2025 |
Brett Stouder |
Pat Starzynski, Theron Vickery, Alan Egilmez, Chris
Hammack |